Home / Health / CDC director’s challenge: Deadly Ebola pathogen and conflict of criticism

CDC director’s challenge: Deadly Ebola pathogen and conflict of criticism

“I am not safeguarding West Africa,” Tom Frieden, pacing in his office, tells an unfortunate U.S. senator on a other finish of a call from Washington. “My series one shortcoming is to strengthen Americans from threats.”

Then: “Respectfully, sir, we don’t determine with you.”

A impulse later: “I wish to recover your confidence.”

When he hangs up, Frieden doesn’t brand a senator, other than to contend that he was a Republican who wants an comprehensive transport anathema on people from West Africa since of a Ebola epidemic. Frieden thinks that’s a misled thought that will backfire, yet a senator would not be assured otherwise.

“It was pingpong round conflicting iron safe,” he says.

Frieden, a 53-year-old alloy who for a past 5 years has served as executive of a Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, is enthralled in an epidemiological and domestic crisis. He has turn a face of that crisis, and some-more than that, a voice. It’s a low voice, sonorous, and he speaks slowly, deliberately, assuredly, and he announced during a finish of September: “I have no doubt that we’ll stop this in a marks in a U.S.”

But his assured statements have had to contest with a assault of bad news, including a infection of dual health-care workers in Dallas, and he is now on a defensive.

Frieden spent many of Thursday on Capitol Hill removing grilled by lawmakers whose concerns were identical to those of a politicians who phoned him Wednesday. They asked: Why not levy a transport ban? How can we be certain someone with Ebola won’t trip into a nation and trigger another unfolding like a one in Dallas?

Frieden answered that a anathema on transport in and out of those countries simply wouldn’t work, since people would still find a approach to pierce conflicting a porous West African borders and eventually make their approach by atmosphere to a United States. Officials during airports wouldn’t know to check their transport story and shade them for fever, and they wouldn’t be means to lane a travelers after and guard them for Ebola symptoms.

But Frieden has unsuccessful to convince critics, including some Democrats, who preference a transport ban.

Ebola has killed some-more than 4,400 people in West Africa and is out of control in Liberia, Sierra Leone and Guinea. Frieden visited West Africa in Aug — going into Ebola wards to see a disaster firsthand — and his apocalyptic news helped coax a Obama administration to ramp adult a response to a epidemic.

In a meantime, a Ebola news in a United States has left from bad to worse.

This is a largest conflict of a Ebola pathogen in history. View Graphic This is a largest conflict of a Ebola pathogen in history.

The “index patient,” Thomas Eric Duncan, brought a illness into a nation from Liberia in September, and a pathogen after putrescent a dual health-care workers during Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital Dallas. That series competence good rise; officials are monitoring scores of workers potentially unprotected to Duncan, who died Oct. 8.

Critics have pronounced that CDC discipline for infection control are too difficult and too tough to follow. A inhabitant nurses kinship pronounced workers had unsound training and protecting equipment. Frieden this week voiced bewail that a CDC hadn’t finished some-more early in a predicament to assistance a Dallas hospital. He also apologized for observant that a “breach in protocol” contingency have occurred in a diagnosis of Duncan; some people had interpreted that as a critique of a sanatorium or of a putrescent helper Nina Pham.

The CDC’s discipline seem to be simply evaded by a virus. Most notably, on Monday a CDC was sensitive by health-care workman Amber Vinson that she was regulating a heat of 99.5 degrees, yet a CDC did not forestall her from boarding a blurb jetliner and drifting from Cleveland to Dallas. Her heat was next a threshold of 100.4 degrees that a group has determined for a screening of travelers from West Africa. The CDC discipline are also dubious on a bearing risk for health-care workers such as Vinson and Pham who were wearing some turn of protecting gear.

One member of Congress, Rep. Tom Marino (R.-Pa.), has already called for Frieden’s resignation, saying, “The reports my colleagues and we have perceived are definitely unacceptable, and a information supposing to a open has been mysterious and in some cases misleading. This has supposing a fake clarity of confidence to many of a citizens. That is accurately a conflicting of a CDC director’s primary responsibilities — to promulgate clearly and honestly.”

But Frieden has defenders. The White House is station by Frieden, yet President Obama suggested Thursday dusk that it competence make clarity to have one chairman coordinating a sovereign response, though regulating a tenure Ebola czar.

And many health-care experts contend it is astray to censure Frieden for a failings of an particular hospital; a CDC provides superintendence and recommendations yet is not a regulatory group with management over health facilities.

“Right now, we consider Frieden is doing accurately a right thing: He’s vocalization honestly, educating, informing and training all during a same time,” pronounced David Rosner, a open health and amicable story highbrow during Columbia University. “He’s operative in a really poisonous domestic sourroundings yet is perplexing to be picturesque and honest as good as informative.”

Michael Osterholm, an outspoken University of Minnesota epidemiologist, this week criticized a overconfidence entrance from U.S. open health experts, observant they should be some-more adult front about a unknowns and uncertainties.

“Let’s acknowledge one thing: We’re creation this adult as we go. And that’s not a bad thing in open health,” Osterholm said.

Many of Frieden’s predictions about a widespread have been accurate. After he returned from West Africa, he warned that a conflict was arching out of control, that interlude it would need an huge and evident response from a tellurian community, and that it was unavoidable that cases would aspect in a United States until Ebola was stopped in West Africa.

Frieden is well-equipped for a highlight that comes with his job. Before Ebola, his biggest veteran plea came in a late 1990s when he was operative in India as a CDC worker reserved to a World Health Organization bid to control a illness epidemic.

“Every day we had to face a existence that if we didn’t work faster, another thousand people were going to die,” he pronounced during an talk Wednesday.

His mom is a late historian and lawyer, his father was a cardiologist. Their 3 sons, Tom, Ken and Jeffry Frieden, are all achieved scholars who stay in tighten hold and are ardent New York Yankees fans.

Ken Frieden remembers his younger hermit Tom sitting for hours during a bedside of his father as he suffered from Parkinson’s disease. The father would tumble asleep, yet Tom would stay and still be during a bedside when a father woke up, Ken said.

Tom Frieden grew adult in a suburban city of Mamaroneck, N.Y., attended Mamaroneck High School, afterwards Oberlin College and finally Columbia University, where he warranted a medical grade and a master’s in open health. He met his mother during Oberlin, and they have dual children; Frieden keeps no family photos in his office, that is a plain space dominated by a vast TV screen.

Before Obama allocated him in May 2009 to conduct a CDC, Frieden had spent 7 years as commissioner of a New York City health department, one of a nation’s largest open health agencies.

Working underneath then-Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg (I), Frieden was a designer of some of Bloomberg’s many argumentative policies, including a citywide anathema on workplace smoking, including restaurants and bars. New York City also became a initial place in a United States to discharge trans fats from restaurants. Earlier, operative in a health department’s illness branch, he satisfied that a city’s debate conflicting antibiotic-resistant illness would need going out and creation certain that patients finished their march of medicine. He set adult a module that did so, including locking adult homeless people if he had to.

To stay focused, Frieden carries with him his daily news and to-do list on an index card. He pronounced he schooled that robe — essay down his tasks — on his initial day as a doctor. For a many critical ones, stay until they are done. When we feel overwhelmed, mangle a problem into tiny parts.

He is famous as data-driven and gets undone when people don’t know that policies need to be evidence-driven and not made by politics.

Frieden’s oldest brother, Jeffry, pronounced that even in infrequent conversation, Tom is always asking, “How do we know that? What’s a justification for that?”

In Frieden’s mind, a justification clearly shows that a United States will not be protected until a Ebola widespread is finished in West Africa. He and other opponents of a transport anathema contend it would bushel service efforts, and that Ebola could turn autochthonous in West Africa, a conditions that would poise a consistent hazard to that continent and by prolongation to a rest of a world.

“Let me tell we what would occur if a pathogen spreads all over Africa and into Asia. That could change a whole approach we hoop health caring here,” he pronounced during one indicate Wednesday, vocalization by phone to a apart lawmaker. His voice rose: “The risks to this nation will be many times larger than it is today.”

There have been many such calls.

“Could we have a few some-more cases? Yes,” he told another senator. “Will we make certain to stop a sequence of transmission? Yes.”

He added: “People are indignant during me, yet I’ve always taken a perspective that when we turn with people and tell a truth, during some point, they will commend that.”

Bernstein and Achenbach reported from Washington. Alice Crites contributed to this report.

More from The Washington Post:

Texas sanatorium apologizes for Ebola mistakes

CDC executive wants hospitals to ‘think Ebola’

First Dallas helper entrance to Bethesda

Ebola fuels fear and stress in U.S.

How Ebola sped out of control

‘The math still favors a virus’

Article source: http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/cdc-directors-challenge-deadly-ebola-virus-and-outbreak-of-criticism/2014/10/16/f0109802-5547-11e4-ba4b-f6333e2c0453_story.html

Scroll To Top