By JACK GILLUM and ERIC TUCKER
WASHINGTON (AP) – The content messages prisoner a cover of unthinkable abuse: Parents had struck their toddler so mostly that they eventually killed her. The child shook badly since we kick her, a father wrote, and a mom complained that their 2-year-old was a devil.
FBI Director James Comey says encrypting information stored on smartphones and computers could harm rapist investigations, and justification reviewed by The Associated Press shows that a child abuse box in Los Angeles from summer 2011 is a powerful, constrained argument. Prosecutors pronounced a texts recovered by investigators stirred a relatives to most desire for a defence deal.
But during slightest 3 other examples a FBI executive has cited are not so cut and dry. They are cases in that a authorities were sloping off – or even solved a crime – by means other than examining information they took from victims or suspects. While digital justification competence have aided those investigations, authorities nonetheless relied on justification over what was stored on a dungeon phone to seize a rapist or secure a conviction.
The onslaught to transparent a FBI’s complaints about new phone encryption underscores a ascending quarrel confronting a Obama administration in a arise of disclosures by former National Security Agency researcher Edward Snowden. Those revelations showed a supervision was collecting phone annals and digital communications of millions not suspected of a crime.
It’s not transparent how a FBI hopes to interpretation a encryption record already rolled out to consumers, such as seeking new legislation on Capitol Hill restricting a use. Congress is approaching to lapse to Washington in Nov to cruise a USA Freedom Act, legislation destined during reining in a NSA’s notice capabilities and providing some-more clarity to tip record in a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court.
The FBI arch on Thursday cited cases involving a sex-offending cab motorist in Louisiana, an violent mom in Los Angeles, a Kansas drug ring and a forward motorist in California, observant any showed a value of law enforcement’s ability to review files on dungeon phones.
“Encryption isn’t usually a technical feature. It’s a selling pitch. But it will have really critical consequences for law coercion and inhabitant confidence agencies during each level,” Comey said, echoing progressing comments after Apple Inc. and Google Inc. pronounced they would encrypt their phones by default.
The government’s concerns competence be destined in partial toward Apple’s iMessage platform, that offers end-to-end encrypted content messages, distinct normal SMS messages. That encryption expected means a usually approach for military to review those messages is by receiving a user’s iPhone. Apple has sole hundreds of millions of inclination that use iMessage.
Most examples a FBI executive cited showed that justification extracted from phones was, during best, supplementary.
Comey forked to a hit-and-run motorist in Sacramento, California, who was convicted of second-degree murder in a 2012 collision that killed a male and 4 dogs, saying, “GPS information placed a motorist during a stage of a collision and suggested that he had fled California shortly thereafter.”
Defense counsel Michael Long, however, removed that a side counterpart found during a stage of a pile-up – taken as justification to a automobile dealership – was an initial idea that led investigators to brand a form of car involved. More breaks came with tips from watcher accounts and unknown tips that placed Paul William Walden during a collision scene.
Walden was arrested entrance out of his drive and certified being benefaction during a collision, a ban acknowledgment presented to a jury. With entrance to his phone, Long said, investigators subpoenaed annals from a dungeon use provider and used dungeon building plcae information to place him nearby a stage – annals that military can customarily obtain even if they don’t physically possess a person’s phone.
“They wouldn’t have had his dungeon phone until they had Paul,” Long said. “The dungeon phone record was really useful for them once they had Paul and they had his phone and his annals to be means to square together his route opposite a country.
“It helped them crook Paul,” he added, “but it didn’t assistance them constraint Paul.” Walden is portion a judgment of 25 years to life.
Another box concerned a heroin trafficking classification in Kansas City, Kansas, whose drug-dealing resulted in mixed drug overdoses.
Court filings uncover that while a suspects organised orders regulating phones they rejected each few weeks, investigators assembled their prosecutions around months of clandestine drug purchases involving trusted informants – a decades-old, some-more required law coercion strategy.
Branden Bell, a counsel for Verdale Handy, of Kansas City, who was convicted of attempted murder of a declare and mixed drug-dealing crimes, pronounced he didn’t remember electronic justification factoring in a charge of his client.
“The government’s justification was a series of people who allegedly purchased narcotics from Mr. Handy and an watcher comment of someone Mr. Handy attempted to murder,” Bell said.
“I trust they followed a normal inquisitive model, identifying lower-level distributors (and getting) their team-work to brand and supply justification opposite a suppliers above that,” he said.
A fourth box concerned a 12-year-old Louisiana child killed by a sex-offender cab motorist who acted online as a immature lady and sent a child content messages.
Comey pronounced a phones of a think and a plant were “instrumental in display that a think enticed this child into his taxi,” yet according to authorities, they initial zeroed in on a think after anticipating his cab parked suspiciously on a highway shoulder and last by a permit check that he was a purebred sex offender. Physical justification also connected a dual after a motorist was arrested, yet authorities have pronounced a electronic justification did breeze adult being critical for conviction.
In response to concerns Comey voiced progressing about phone encryption, The Associated Press asked a Justice Department some-more than dual weeks ago about specific cases in that encryption competence have hindered law enforcement. The FBI eventually pronounced Comey’s debate this week was dictated to yield those examples.
Police contend there is infrequently good evidentiary value in content messages, quite involving gang-related homicides where eyewitnesses are scarcely nonexistent and assailants gloat about their misdeeds. In a Los Angeles case, for instance, texts showed a settlement of abuse and cover among a girl’s relatives – even as their daughter was on life support.
“They knew those content messages couldn’t have been put in front of a jury,” pronounced Los Angeles sheriff’s Sgt. Richard Biddle, who investigated a case. “It showed how cruel they were. They didn’t caring about a kid. They usually cared about themselves.”
Follow Jack Gillum on Twitter during https://twitter.com/jackgillum and Eric Tucker during https://twitter.com/etuckerap.
Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This element competence not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.